|
Since
the last Islamic revolution in Iran, Islamic law
has replaced former secular law. When applied to
capital punishment, this means that families are
granted ownership of the offender's life--they can
take retribution or can offer forgiveness. This
forms the background for Producer/Director/Writer
Hamid Rahmanian's intriguing Day Break
(Dame sobh), recently
released on DVD through Film Movement.
Set in Tehran's century-old
prison the film opens inside the mind of Mansour
(Hossein Yari), as we see one of many flashbacks—marvelous
footage of a train journey through the green countryside
of northern Iran into a tunnel and the morning of
Mansour's crime. He's unquestionably committed murder,
but now his life hangs in the balance depending
on what the victim's family decides. Mansour is
awakened at daybreak for a medical exam (no sick
person can be executed), and he is scheduled to
face the victim's family for the third time; they
did not show up the previous two times.
Mansour and another death
row inmate enter the execution room. Only one bench
is filled--Mansour's final judges have yet to make
their appearance, but he is assured that the family
is on the way. That gives us all a chance to see
Islamic justice at work. Confronted by an embittered
family member who appears set on retribution, the
condemned murderer sobs and begs for his life. The
judge also implores the family to consider granting
mercy to no avail; the prisoner continues to pitifully
plea for his life. It's almost a relief for the
man to be ordered to step up for his hanging, but
at the very last instant a bargain is struck--his
life in exchange for his house and property to be
used for an orphanage. After witnessing mostly negative
media coverage about Islamic justice, it's quite
refreshing to see a different view--a humanistic
way of allowing the victims to act as the final
judge.
Meanwhile, Mansour learns
that his execution has once again been postponed.
A phone call from the family informs that there
was a death in the family, so they must wait the
traditionally prescribed 40 days before attending
to Mansour's pending execution. While this news
is usually cause for celebration, Mansour sees this
as worse than death. The continual state of purgatory
has been working on his mind, much like Dostoevsky's
psychological study in Crime and Punishment.
Rahmanian masterfully takes
us inside Mansour's mind via flashbacks and his
day to day existence inside the prison; he rehashes
past turning points like the decision he makes for
the family to move from their village to Tehran,
and becomes more and more withdrawn to the point
of becoming suicidal. It's a psychological struggle
that we all can relate to; we've all done something
that we've regretted. This shows how obsessive the
guilty mind can become and how difficult it can
be to move on with Life. Of course, Mansour is physically
confined, but this is far less important than the
emotional/spiritual restrictions that he places
on himself. That much makes the film universal.
Paying homage to Iran's
greatest filmmaker, Rahmanian offers recognizable
touches of Abbas Kiaroastami's work--most noticeably
near the beginning when the medical examiner narrates
a portion. Cinematographer Byrom Fazli's minimalist
camera follows the examiner inside a moving car,
and soon we confront the prison guards to create
a "film within a film." When they examine the credentials
and granted permissions for the project called Day
Break, the filmmaker is allowed inside,
and the remainder of the film flows seamlessly through
its well-paced 85 minutes. Some American audiences
may feel uncomfortable with the "ambiguous" ending,
but if they watch close enough, they should realize
that the ending is of little importance—it's the
journey that is worth watching. It signals once
again that Iranian filmmaking remains a force in
world cinema, and that Hamid Rahmanian is a filmmaker
to keep an eye out for.
|