|
Everyone
knows that cigarettes are bad for you. If you doubt
that, why do audiences laugh at the 1950's cigarette
ads in George Clooney's Good Night and
Good Luck? Cigarettes contributed
to Edward R. Murrow's premature death and to thousands
of other addicts, but that doesn't mean that the
most effective way to combat tobacco is through
a 60 Minutes style expose. Satirically
slashing through the smoke rings spun by the tobacco
lobby, director Jason Reitman delivers Thank
You for Smoking in the same spirit
as Saturday Night Live (during its peak
years of Belushi, Aykroyd, Radner, & company).
Professional tobacco lobbyist
Nick Naylor (Aaron Eckhart) officially serves as
spokesperson for the Academy of Tobacco Studies,
and uses his likability and gifts for verbal spin
dynamically. Early on, he is the invited "villain"
on The Joan Lunden Show, seated next to bald-headed
15-year old Robin, who is dying from lung cancer.
Naylor deftly turns the tables on his anti-smoking
stage rivals by declaring that the tobacco industry
wants to keep smokers like Robin alive—that it's
in their best interests. "The anti-smoking people
want Robin to die," he declares, citing how this
would play into their self interests.
Naylor is great at what
he does. As he describes his profession: "Michael
Jordan plays ball. Charlie Manson kills people.
I talk." Naylor uses his verbal dexterity throughout,
even unleashing it with subtle charm during a career
day presentation in his son's elementary school
class when a young girl asserts that her mother
says that cigarettes can kill you. "Oh, is your
mother a doctor? ... A scientific researcher of
some kind?" The girl is easily disarmed; we are
once again amused by the cleverness of Reitman's
clever screenplay and Eckhart's flawless delivery.
As optimistic and positive
as any successful CEO, Naylor isn't perfect, however.
His personal life doesn't match his professional
life, as most clearly illustrated by his divorced
state. He also easily reveals inside information
to newspaper reporter Heather Holloway (Katie Holmes)
that nearly destroys his career—a result of talking
far too much when in the throes of sexual passion.
Despite personal flaws, Naylor remains a godlike
hero to his son Joey (Cameron Bright), who eagerly
seeks and accepts his father's advice. Joey learns
life lessons by accompanying his father on a business
trip and adopts his attitude to win a scholastic
debating contest -- "If you argue right, you ARE
right."
Although Eckhart clearly
carries the narrative, the film works largely due
to the skills of the large ensemble cast that act
as separate skits and add humorous variety. Most
prominent is the small Washington D.C. group that
Naylor joins weekly for lunch. Calling themselves
the MOD squad (which stands for Merchants of Death),
the other two are alcohol lobbyist Polly Bailey
(Maria Bellow) and firearms lobbyist Bobby Jay Bliss
(David Koechner). Dark humor abounds as they argue
over which industry best practices "population control,"
or commiserate over strategy to overcome their latest
obstacle—the alcohol lobbyist has a tough task overcoming
a deformed baby issue.
Another highlight takes
place in Hollywood as Naylor visits movie agent
Jeff Megall (Rob Lowe) to gain prominent product
placement. Cigarettes just aren't making a good
impression in modern movies, as Reitman astutely
references in their tightly scripted dialog. They
note that only villains and Europeans smoke, so
the tobacco industry wants positive box office clout
to promote their product—millions of production
money would back a deal for a big time smoking role
model. Megall astutely asserts that the movie would
have to avoid the modern era because people would
question why the good guy is smoking, so they must
think of period pieces or venture into the future—cigarettes
in space. So, he'll talk to Sony about having Brad
Pitt and Catherine Zeta Jones chain smoke throughout
their steamy futuristic flick.
Other good moments include
William H. Macy as a crusading Vermont Senator,
who wants to require oversized skull & crossbones
warnings on cigarette packs, and Sam Elliott as
Lorne Lutch, the original Marlboro Man who is currently
lambasting the tobacco industry after being diagnosed
with cancer. Both find themselves on the defense--Macy
for his state's contributions to clogged arteries
and Elliott attempting to decide how to deal with
a generous gift offering. The latter is a moral
quandary that expertly exposes basic human nature
without overt preaching, and that ranks as a major
strength of Reitman's entire film.
He never clobbers the audience
over the head with his message, but provocatively
delivers while entertaining us with a very smart
and witty satire. Although the film drags slightly
in the middle when Eckhart is briefly sidetracked
with romantic interest, the tightly scripted comedy
begins and ends strong. Thank You for
Smoking delivers a breath of fresh
air to the big screen--92 minutes of quality satire
that match the tone of Tex Williams lively opening
song from yesteryear, "Smoke, Smoke, Smoke That
Cigarette!" Given a choice between lecture and laughter,
it's not difficult to figure which direction a movie
should take for higher audience share; and in this
case, it's the most effective course.
|